I don't know if I like the story in this movie better than Knives Out. I saw a few things online over the winter, to where I had a pretty good idea who the murderer was going in, so I can't assess the quality of the mystery. It seemed pretty obvious who Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig), and Miss Brand (Janelle Monae) were ignoring as a suspect in the lengthy flashback that occurs halfway through the movie, but, would I have noticed that going into the movie entirely cold? I like to think so, if only because the character was such an obvious shithead it would really be no surprise that they turned out to be the killer all along.
But the explanation for why Blanc takes so long to figure it out, because of his peculiar weakness, was at least well-established for comedic effect early and often, and then paid off at the end. Chekov's Blind Spot. Craig seems to be having a lot of fun with the character, and even the amping up of his folksy Southern charm has a reason.
The setting is excellent. The whole ridiculous, overdone, faux-visionary design of the island. The sliding panel over the painting, which is triggered by someone getting alerts on their phone, because the "hack" was shoddily done. The random presence of Derol, who I spent the entire movie waiting to see if he would actually be important, or if he was really just some guy Miles Bron (Ed Norton) was letting hang around while he figured out some stuff.
Norton also seems to be having fun with Bron. I mean, I hope he had fun playing an Elon Musk stand-in. An imbecile who perceives himself as brilliant and visionary, but is basically the equivalent of a five-year-old saying, "What if the duck pooped ketchup?" To be fair, Norton is always good at playing guys I'd kinda like to see get punched in the face (him and Jonah Hill both), so this is right in his wheelhouse. There's a flashback when Blanc does his big explanation, where Bron gets a fax and he's wearing an old-school Adidas tracksuit with the collar popped, no less. Perfect look, somehow just said everything about the character.
Sadly, Edward Norton does not get punched in this movie (Jonah Hill doesn't get punched either, but he's not in the movie.) I was hoping it would happen right at the end, but the way things went was, mostly fine. I guess. I mean, yes, it's going to be a whole thing for his reputation, but the painting did get destroyed, which kind of sucks for humanity. Whereas, if he just gets punched in the face, the only person harmed is him! And maybe the knuckles of whoever punched him.