Sunday Splash Page #68

"Cass' Hatred of Circuses Was a Source of Strife Between her and Nightwing," in Batgirl #28, by Kelley Puckett (writer), Daimon Scott (penciler), Robert Campanella (inker), Jason Wright (colorist), John Costanza (letterer)

I didn't start buying the Cass Cain Batgirl series until after the abysmal War Games storyline. It was several years after that before I backtracked to the earlier issues, by the original creative team of Kelley Puckett and Daimon Scott.

Puckett and Scott handled most of the first three years of the series (excluding issues done by various fill-in artists, including Phil Noto, who isn't a bad artist, but it's whiplash inducing going from Scott's style to his.)

The first two years deal with Cass gaining the ability to speak, but losing the ability that lets her fight so effectively in the process. Regaining it puts her on a collision course with Lady Shiva, a battle Cass knows she can't win. In among all that is Cass trying to sort out her feelings about her father, the assassin David Cain, Oracle trying to protect Cass and get her to experience the world, and Batman being sort of distant. Trusting Cassandra to figure things out for herself, perhaps. 

(The writers who followed Puckett veered heavily into making Batsy an overbearing dickhead who tries to control Cass and keeps threatening to take the costume away for arbitrary reasons. He does that once during Puckett's run, but it's because Cass has no ability to defend herself, only attack, which is fairly reasonable.)

This is also the start of Cass and Stephanie Brown's friendship, so it has that going for it. There are a few pieces, mostly in the last year of the Puckett/Scott run, that don't really pay off. The three beings in the image above, being one of them. It never does seem to get established who they're controlled by. There are also a lot of issues tying into whatever Bat-event was happening that I didn't care about. Joker: Last Laugh, Bruce Wayne: Murderer, that one where Commissioner Gordon got shot. Puckett and Scott usually do their best to work with those, but the stories aren't about Cass, so it's hard to give a shit.

This stretch of his career is far and away my favorite for Daimon Scott. I actually first encountered his work during Bill Willingham's Robin run, which came several years after this. I wasn't a fan then, because Scott seemed to have gone so far into his own style he couldn't tell a story clearly. You can see some of the same tendencies in this run, but they're more reined in. Full-page splashes don't really do justice to his work on Batgirl, because I think his real skill was in laying out sequences of action. Cass isn't much for talking, she does stuff, fights, moves, and Scott really captures that. Whether it's a fight between her and Shiva, or her barely stifling a yawn sparring with Spoiler, or moving from rooftop to rooftop, Scott captures the sense of how smoothly and easily she can do those things.