Convergence: Batgirl #2, by Alisa Kwitney (writer), Rick
Leonardi (penciller), Mark Pennington (inker), Steve Buccellato (colorist), Tom
Napolitano (lettering) – While that isn’t the greatest cover – looks like an
enlarged panel – it is kind of nice to see Steph rushing to the aid of her
friend. I miss that.
Steph wins by convincing Catman to give up, so that the
fight will be over and he can trick Grodd into being dragged back to their city
together. Steph was prepared to throw the fight herself, if that was what it
came to. We also learn in flashback that Tim pretty much broke off all contact
with Steph when she hung up the costume, without so much as a world of
explanation, and now that she’s back in it, he’s trying to start things up
again.
I was going to say that doesn’t seem much like Tim, but
there was a stretch in Jon Lewis’ run on Robin where Tim rightfully got fed up
with Batman’s crap, and considered giving up the costume. He asked Steph if
she’d still want to be with him if was plain ol’ Tim Drake. Now Steph, responded
with an affirmative, but that does point in the direction of how Tim sees their
relationship. That said, I was surprised Cassandra seemed so irritated by the
happy couple stuff at the end. Maybe it was the fact she got a faceful of it as
soon as she woke up from being pummeled by super-strong, telepathic gorilla.
Still, I would have expected her to be more amused by it, or quietly satisfied.
The two issues are nothing special. Convergence is an
inconsequential placeholder event, so that’s maybe to be expected. Still, I
thought Kwitney had a reasonably good grasp of the characters, and I can chalk
any variances from my expectations up to the unusual circumstances they lived
under (though, as Steph noted in the first issue, they already lived through No
Man’s Land. This is different only in the fact they didn’t know who had cut
them off from everything). Leonardi’s work is still not his best, which is
still disappointing. The faces seem better, and there’s more action in this
issue, which is always something Leonardi’s drawn well. There’s something about
the way he draws punches, the characters really seem to put their whole body
into it, but in a way that makes sense. You can tell they’re pushing off the
ground or the wall or whatever, if that’s the case. Little things can help make
the difference, sometimes.
Daredevil #15, by Chris Samnee and Mark Waid (storytellers),
Matthew Wilson (colorist), Joe Caramagna (letterer) – Wouldn’t that cover be
more appropriate for issue 13, where Kirsten is
confronted by her arch-nemesis? Also, who is the person in the panel at the
bottom, with the seemingly empty speech balloon? It looks like they have some
sort of a mechanical jaw. Oh no, has Silvermane’s head killed the Shocker and
retaken control of the Maggia?
Matt drags Jubula out of her fight with the Shroud, because
he feels their outmatched. He has no idea how much, because Shroud’s been using
the Owl to record everything going on in Matt’s life going back a while. Which
he then projects throughout San Francisco. So everyone knows Foggy isn’t dead,
and where he lives. Everyone sees Matt and Kirsten’s physically and emotionally
intimate moments. And Max makes it look as though Matt recorded every
conversation he had with clients, which is real bad. And then Matt shows up at
the Deputy Mayor’s office to explain, so Max releases footage of her being the
weapons supplier for the guys who kidnapped the D.M.’s daughter in the first
issue. So now everyone’s after Matt, and Jubula knows the one person who can
fix it all: Wilson Fisk. Maybe Matt’s better off dealing with the cops and the
bar association.
Honestly, I didn’t even know Fisk was supposed dead until
Matt mentioned he thought that was the case. I don’t see how Fisk is going to
fix all this, even if he were so inclined, and assuming he doesn’t demand a
price Matt deems too high, but considering the shitstorms Wilson has skated
through clean in the past, I can’t put it past him. I did find it amusing
Fisk’s goons hauled Matt in by both arms. You’d think they wouldn’t bother.
Fisk has a better chance of whupping Matt alone if he tries something than they
do.
Let’s talk the color in the book a bit. I notice Jubula’s
reminisce about her father is shaded in the same sort of light blue as the
light from all those wires and screens her dad’s hooked up to. Representing
information, knowledge, or a shorthand for scenes involving the Owl in some
way? The first page, Matt in the shadows, all the red he’s wearing washed out
or absorbed by them. Samnee’s art helps, of course, the way Matt’s posed makes
him look like a lost man trying to feel his way, something we aren’t accustomed
to seeing. But the very different color scheme for him makes it look a bit
alien, like he’s in another world entirely. It was a very effective opening
move.
2 comments:
Daredevil has been uniformly magnificent. Convergence has been...as you say...a place holder. I am glad to see so many of my beloved charaters however, so there is that.
Someone else remarked that they still knew the history of the beloved OLD characters far better than the new 52 versions, but apparently that means nothing to DC.
I think Cass was squicked out more because she could read Tim and Steph's body language than anything else (and could see they wanted to, err, get CLOSE).
At least, that's how I see it here on Earth-Earl :)
Thanks for posting!
Post a Comment