Laid up with a broken leg he got taking a risky photo at a car race, L.B. Jeffries (Jimmy Stewart) is whiling away his recovery during the hot summer months by spying on all his neighbors. This, when he could be enjoying time with his high-society girlfriend, Lisa Fremont (Grace Kelly.) Clearly, Jeffries is even more lacking in judgement than the backstory behind his injury suggests.
Late one night, he hears a scream somewhere outside. Soon, the salesman across the courtyard is making several trips out at 3 in the morning. In the pouring rain. With a suitcase. Mr. Thorvald's (Raymond Burr) wife is an invalid, but Thorvald seems to ignore her the entire next day. In fact, with the blinds down in their bedroom window, Jeffries doesn't know what's going on with the wife. But with Thorvald busy wrapping up saws and knives in the kitchen, Jeffries certainly has notions. If only he had some proof.
Rear Window is my favorite Hitchcock movie. When I took a film class as an undergrad, I did my final paper on it. I wished I saved it, just to mine for ideas, but I tossed everything not related to my major in various de-cluttering efforts years ago, including that essay. I know I wrote about the connection between orange lighting and impending violence. (Lighting was something I wrote about often in that class. Camera angles, too.) The faint light of Thorvald's cigarette, representing his anger and desperation, temporarily sated, as he sits in total darkness in his apartment after murdering the middle-aged married couple's little dog. The deep orange sunset in the sky beyond the courtyard during Jeffries and Lisa's conversation the night before the murder. The orange wash over the screen when Jeffries uses the flashbulbs to try and stave off Thorvald's assault.
I love how contained the movie is. The cast is essentially 5 people: Jeffries, Lisa, Thorvald, Jeffries' physical therapist Stella (Thelma Ritter), and his war buddy-turned-detective Doyle (Wendell Corey). The settings are Jeffries' apartment - really just his living room, we barely see anything else - and Thorvald's apartment. The latter we only see from a distance, through Jeffries' binoculars or the telephoto lens on his camera. Maybe throw in the courtyard, with the importance of the garden, but again, only observed at a distance. Doyle is doing the legwork, checking Jeffries' theories (and mostly shooting them down), going places we never see. The train station, Thorvald's mailbox (curious that Doyle is worried about the necessity of a search warrant to go through Thorvald's apartment, but thought nothing of lifting a postcard from the mailbox. Isn't tampering with mail a federal offense?)
With all he reports, we have to take his word. If he's an unreliable observer - he's certainly uninterested - we have no way to confirm. We see a woman depart in the night with Thorvald while Jeffries sleeps, but not the alleged Mrs. Throvald who departed on the train, or who came to pick up all the luggage Thorvald shipped. All we have are Jeffries' and Lisa's suspicions, each of which Doyle has a pat answer to that sound perfectly reasonable in the light of day.
Night is a different matter. There are things unseen there, no matter how good your telephoto lens is. Things sit in the shadows, or behind blinds, out of sight. That let's the imagination run, Jeffries' and ours. We're both trapped in his apartment. Spectators. Safe, but with limited ability to alter events. At least, until the action comes to him. For all his fear for Lisa's safety, Jeffries is the one who ends up hurt. Stella's stated disapproval of his voyeurism early in the film, carrying the tinge of prophecy: Trouble.
Everyone else is there for the menagerie of romantic relationships. The newlyweds spend most of the movie hidden behind the blinds of their bedroom window, up to something very different from Thorvald. The middle-aged couple, fine sleeping on the fire escape for relief from the heat. Nothing going on with them that needs hiding from nosy eyes. The newlyweds are caught up in passion and hormones, while the middle-aged couple have settled into comfortable co-existence. Miss Torso and her stream of male visitors. The composer with his constant parties and visitors that don't fulfill him. Miss Lonelyhearts, losing faith she'll find someone to love.
Lisa turns out to be correct in her assessment Miss Torso doesn't care about the wolves circling her, and is simply waiting for the man she does love to return. Feels a little like Jeffries and Lisa themselves, him disappearing to some distant corner of the world for weeks or months at a time. Miss Lonelyhearts and the composer find something together, but we see only a brief glimpse. This could be the more mature equivalent of what the newlyweds were up to for most of the film, and by the end of the movie we see the bride on her husband's case about being unemployed.
Then there's Thorvald, in a marriage he dislikes, a wife he resents caring for and who appears all too aware of the resentment and belittles him in return. It's unclear when the antagonism started, or from which end, but it passed the point of reconciliation. And there's another woman in the shadows he wants to run away with.
Doyle, in addition to doing legwork for Jeffries, and reminding him of the existence of laws, represents the archetypical marriage. He and the wife have at least one kid, they go out for dinner and dancing occasionally. That doesn't stop Doyle lecherously appreciating Miss Torso from afar, or suggesting he, Jeffries and Lisa sit around into the wee hours, drinking brandy and talking about the war. Not too eager to get home. Stella's married, though all we know is she and her husband fell in love as maladjusted misfits and, according to Stella, remain maladjusted misfits in love decades later.
Not that Jeffries wants to hear that. He does care for Lisa, but the insistence she's not cut out for his life is less concern for her - why not give her a chance to accompany him on an assignment and see if she likes it? - and more an excuse not to let the relationship progress beyond it's current status. Because he's not going to change. He likes the thrill of his work, the danger. Taking photos of models or the latest fashion would bore him. But he also won't break things off with Lisa.
She leaves, feelings hurt, which certainly seems to be his goal. During their argument over the fancy dinner she had delivered, he says he's more than happy to get vicious if that's what she wants. From my perspective, she never got anything approaching vicious with him. It seems like an overreaction, or, again, an excuse to be mean and kill this thing before it advances.
But Lisa comes back the next night, and, whatever he says about them not fitting, Jeffries lets her in. As long as nothing about his life has to change, as long as no new responsibilities or expectations are placed upon him, he's fine continuing their relationship.
Honestly, it's hard for me to see what Lisa sees in Jeffries. Maybe that he's different from the rest of her friends and acquaintances? Kelly plays Lisa as someone who, beneath the high-society gloss and manners, is eager to get up to mischief, to face a little danger. However she and Jeffries crossed paths, she must have seen someone with a knack for finding trouble, and liked it.
So she works to prove she can fit into his world, whatever he says. She'd have to live from a single suitcase? She comes to spend the night with a single travel case. They might encounter people who meant them harm? She sneaks into Thorvald's apartment to get evidence, swiping the late Mrs. Thorvald's wedding ring. She wasn't discreet in signaling to Jeffries, but he wasn't exactly discreet sitting there with the lights on where anyone could see him.
As for Jeffries interest in Lisa, well, the man has eyes, even if he's often too busy looking at something other than what's right in front of him. Stewart uses that twitchy, stammering approach to give Jeffries a nervous energy. He's an adrenaline junkie going stir-crazy stuck in that wheelchair. He can't stay in one place, can't sleep in bed, would rather be in the chair so he can move around a little. So he snoops, first with his eyes, then the binoculars, then his camera. He lives vicariously through the lives of his neighbors, as we live vicariously through the danger he puts himself and Lisa in.
And he does start to see that she's made of sterner stuff than he gave her credit for. When she returns after delivering the letter, having evaded Thorvald, Hitchcock lingers on Jeffries, who is practically beaming at her. He's likely thinking something to the effect of how he couldn't have done better himself. Near the end, even with the danger and Lisa's looming night in jail, he can't keep from gushing to Doyle about how slick and quick-thinking she was.
Another point for Stella. She told him the problem these days (meaning the 1950s) was everyone had to analyze everything about themselves and their partner, rather than just going with their feelings. Jeffries tried to dispute that, and got talked over, but once he stopped focusing on all his reasons why he and Lisa won't work, his heart is very plain about the fact that it wants them to work. Jeffries doesn't want Lisa Fremont out of his life.
Whether they're going to make it work once his busted legs are healed is another matter. Lisa seems willing to play by the rules he expects, at least when he's awake and aware. Once he's asleep, she puts away that book on Kilimanjaro, and goes back to reading a magazine. Is that a viable long-term strategy, her leading a double life based on whether he's paying attention? Maybe she expects to wait him out, or wear him down. If the danger is too great a couple of times, would Jeffries renew his conviction she's unsuited for his life, or make changes himself to accommodate her? I don't know.







