The title refers to a hypothesis Asphaug and a colleague named Martin Jutzi developed regarding a massive impact between what became the Moon and another body in the aftermath of the collision between Earth and the body called "Theia." The hypothesis started with the nature of differences between the sides of the Moon. Certain areas of the surface, a thousand kilometers across, that show less cratering than expected, or are covered by matter that would have to be from the mantle, to an extent not seen elsewhere on the surface. Also, there are localized, minute variations in gravity due to compositional differences that might be best explained if two bodies, formed from different masses, smashed together to form a new celestial body, but didn't mix completely in the process.
I'll mention here the copy I read was an uncorrected proof. Not sure how the regional library in the next county over got ahold of it to put in a used book sale, but they did. So there's a page for an index, but no actual index. The Table of Contents lists chapters, but the page numbers for the chapters are all "000." The numbering on the footnotes in the chapters doesn't always line up with what's in the Notes. Spelling errors and at one point, a sentence starts with, 'Gravity' and just ends. I'm not sure if all the photos are meant to be black-and-white, and frequently grainy to the point illegibility, but they are.
Point being, I may not be getting the proper experience of reading this. Because it comes off as in dire need of tighter focus. Broadly, the entire book is moving in the direction of describing this idea about the collision between Theia and Earth creating more than one satellite for Earth for a brief period, and then those satellites collided and became our current Moon. But Asphaug takes a meandering path to get there. I reached the end of most chapters, only to pause and realize I wasn't sure what specific point he'd been trying to make.
Chapter 3, "Systems Inside Systems," starts with how large planets are unfinished stars, shifts to the difference in how planets form near and far from the Sun. From there, he starts in on collisional physics, since the final formation for terrestrial bodies is thought to be the largest clumps of matter that managed to avoid being swept up by the Sun ramming into each other. This is, due to the size of the bodies involved, not like a meteor hitting the Earth. The impacts are not much greater than escape velocity, and slow enough you could enjoy a cup of coffee while it happened.
Then, within the same chapter, he starts talking about surfaces. Gas giants don't have surfaces, a point where liquid meets solid, but terrestrial bodies do. Then it's on to hydrologic cycles on Earth, the exchange of oxygen between the surface of the ocean and the air, the lack of water on Venus, the possibility of where life could exist elsewhere in the Solar System. The chapter ends on the notion life on Earth was seeded from life on Mars, carried here on material ejected from the Red Planet by impacts on its surface back when it still had water. Impacts of smaller meteorites, mind you, not the "giant impacts" he was describing earlier in the chapter while discussing planet formation.
(The idea life survived inside a rock hurtling through airless space for the months or years it would take for said rock to cross the distance between Earth and Mars, then survived entry into Earth's atmosphere and either the explosion of the meteor, or its high-speed collision with the planet, has always seemed bizarre to me. Aspaugh talks about the meteors being large enough to retain some of the heat of the impact internally, and I know there is life on Earth that not only doesn't need oxygen, oxygen is actively poisonous to it. So the airless part is maybe not an issue. Still, even Archean bacteria here on Earth need something to subsist on.)
I can see a throughline in the discussion of interfaces, be it two celestial objects, or two distinct states of matter. But built into a single chapter, it feels too diffuse. What step this is in the process to the climax of the book is unclear. Especially since he keeps coming back around to impacts and gravitational effects of the Sun at other points before and after this. It would have been more straightforward to start with smaller impacts, then scale up to how impacts relate to planetary creation. Or go the other way, discuss planetary creation, the large-scale effect of the Sun's gravity on what's available and what's feasible, then drill down into the mechanics of the impacts.
Basically, I needed a tighter focus. Asphaug spends a lot of pages discussing exoplanets. Mostly to describe how unusual our solar system seems from the observations of those orbiting other starts. He says they have never found an exoplanet in the general size and composition of Earth or Venus. It's much more common to find either super sized Earths, or smaller, hotter Neptunes. OK, that's neat, but unless you understand why those planetary systems are different, it doesn't really help explain why our Solar System is why it is.
He mentions a theory our Solar System had super-Earths and hot Neptunes, and they got destroyed during a period where whatever stable orbits they were settling into got unbalanced and everything started colliding again. So you're telling me all these exoplanet systems we've found are younger than ours and just haven't gotten to that point yet? Otherwise, we're back to our solar system being weird for having gone through an anomalous, additional, "bumper cars" stage, for some undiscovered reason.
Based on his repeated reference to orbital resonance between several of Saturn's satellites, as well as Jupiter's Io, Europa and Ganymede, I think he's going for the idea the super-Earths and hot Neptunes were in orbital resonance until something disrupted this, resulting in chaos. He brings it up as being part of the history of Saturn's moons. So does that require the discussion of the exoplanets? It's certainly neat, but feels like an unnecessary digression here.
'Phobos and Deimos are not asteroids per se, although not long ago the mainstream idea was that they were interlopers captured from the Main belt. They sure look like asteroids, these dark reddish cratered clods. But capture around a planet is extremely unlikely. It's like throwing a tennis ball into the open window of a moving car several streets away, but a lot harder. If the encounter was too fast, they would not be captured; if too slow, they would impact the planet.'
No comments:
Post a Comment