
It's a solid enough issue, as DeFalco/Frenz continue to convince me that bringing Carnage back into play wasn't a horrible mistake. They spend a brief moment covering what Mary Jane is up to, before turning the focus to May and Peter (who gets one of those classic Spidey moments where he triumphs through will and determination. It's not up there with lifting all that rubble to get the medical serum in Amazing Spider-Man #33, but it's not bad). Frenz does his usual solid job, and it's got pretty decent momentum for a middle chapter of a multi-issue arc (at least by today's standards). 3.8 out of 5.

Ronan seems in an odd place, infected by the Phalanx, obedient, but still free enough to be pissed at his situation. I have a feeling that means something, as does Super-Skrull's current resistance, and what Wraith said about why the Phalanx fear him, but it's a thought that needs more work. Mr. Hotz' work is dark and moody, and appropriately creepy for what seems very much like a horror movie, but on the whole I didn't enjoy this issue that much. It felt cheap to just get all of Wraith's origin in one setting like we did. 2.9 out of 5.

Olliffe's artwork is more to my liking than Scot Eaton's was, personally. Because really, if you're going to do a story where the bad guys conquer a country, and the good guys will have several skirmishes with the bad guys, then you need someone who can draw good fight scenes, and I think Olliffe does that better than Eaton did. Better representation of movement, force, action, however you want to describe it. Knows when to go close-up, or wide-angle.
Things feel too disjointed in this issue. Both sides have forces scattered all over, and I think it would have helped to have a quick stop over at Captain Britain's location. After all, the previous issue ended with Dark Jean freaking out as she telepathically senses Dark Scott's death; you'd think they might want to touch on that. Did she go comatose, or Dark Phoenix? Has she dissolved the Dark X-Men's partnership with Excalibur? Is she charging towards London as we speak? Or trying to vent her fury on Lionheart/Captain Britain/The Queen, etc.? 2.4 out of 5.
And what the heck was up with the second-to-last page, with the 13-panel death of Dark Beast?

No, it's not ROM. No, I don't know when ROM's going to show up and save the day. Hopefully soon. Whereas Wraith is taking more of a horror approach to the Phalanx (with large, and seemingly painful methods of maintaining control), Nova is going for more of a Indiana Jones feel, since it seems to mix fighting with some humor (the reactions of the other Kree to Ko-Rel's new outfit), plus the Phalanx conversion isn't portrayed as nearly so painful or difficult (unless someone was playing opossum there at the end). Which I guess makes Worldmind Sean Connery. "Your mother liked it ruff Ko-Rel!" I'm very sorry about that. 3.9 out of 5.

So the Huber fellow has an idea to save mutants, and he wants Jamie to spearhead the idea. It's an interesting idea, one that probably fits within the letter of the law, though I can't imagine some of the people it applies to being very happy about it. I agree with Guido though, people around X-Factor used to have a sense of humor, and even laugh at stuff. I laughed at his "skink" pun though, so maybe that counts for something. Can you believe my spellcheck doesn't recognize skink? It's a type of reptile! Stupid worthless spellcheck. Where was I?
Siryn and Monet seem like they're going to have a bit more trouble completing this mission than they planned (imagine that!), and I'm curious to see whether that ties into Huber somehow. Seeing as so many things seem to be connected in this book, I'm thinking there must be some connection, but I can't guess at what. It's a solid issue, mostly set-up. but with some amusing moments, and it was just sort of there. I may be starting to take X-Factor for granted. 3.5 out of 5.
5 comments:
Is it me or is Siryn going for Hal Jordanesque levels when it comes to getting hit in the head? And I actually like Layla, so I hope that Nicole gets hers.
I found Nova to be ok, but a tad on the convoluted side.
And yes, I caught that Green Lantern crack.
Harumph!
I like idea of declaring mutants an endangered species and I kinda thought I was a moron for not making the connection earlier (since the term is splattered at the top of the cover). X-Factor was good this week and I really hope this isn't the end for Layla because I love what David's done with her. Glad to see the bad-guy from the Madrox series back too. On the bad side, did we really need The Age of Apolcalyse to make a come back? If they somehow tie in Onslaught I may just have to consider the X-Men dead to me.
sallyp: Aw, I make jokes about Green Lanterns because I love! Well, actually no, it's because it's easy and fun, but you know what I mean.
As for Siryn, well, she is Irish, and being part-Irish myself, we do tend to lead with our heads.
jason: I haven't read the Madrox series mini-series, who's the enemy? Clay?
I've got no use for AoA myself, and hopefully Onslaught stays safely locked up in that Loeb/Liefeld mini-series, where it can't harm anyone (except those foolish enough to inflict it on themselves).
Yeah, Clay was in the Madrox series, he has the same powers as Jamie. I'd highly recommend getting the trade since it pretty much sets up the current X-Factor series.
jason: Well, i guess I better add that to my list of stuff to search for, next to "issues of GrimJack after #55", and "Suicide Squad".
Post a Comment