Saturday, January 20, 2024

Saturday Splash Page #108

 
"Judgement's Due," in Supergirl (vol. 3) #48, by Peter David (writer), Leonard Kirk (penciler), Robin Riggs (inker), Gene D'Angelo (colorist), Bill Oakley (letterer)

As mentioned last week, one effect of Crisis on the Infinite Earths was to make Superman the only Kryptonian again. But DC couldn't put the Supergirl idea away entirely, so we got the. . .unusual "Matrix" Supergirl. I'm only vaguely up on her backstory. Something about an alternate reality, a Luthor with a full head and beard of red hair? Made of pink, protoplasmic goo, has telekinetic powers.

I don't know where he got the notion, and I'm a little surprised DC let him do it, but Peter David combined Supergirl with a young woman named Linda Danvers, to create a composite person. Linda's memories, but filtered more through Matrix's perceptions and attitudes.

The first year is largely Supergirl figuring out what's happened to her, how it happened, and what things are going to be like for her going forward. This involves a lot of Linda's friends and acquaintances trying to figure out the 180 she's pulled in personality, and "Mae" realizing the girl she's merged with wasn't quite what she figured at first glance. It also involves a demon called Buzz, who is a persistent source of both advice and irritation for almost the entire series.

Around the end of the first year, Leonard Kirk takes over as regular penciler from Gary Frank. Kirk and Riggs' art tends to soften Supergirl's appearance relative to Frank's, who had more of a thin, sharp edge to faces and expressions (though he hadn't drifted into the overly busy and stiff work he would by the time he's working with Geoff Johns a lot.) While Kirk's fully capable of drawing a furious Supergirl, he rounds jawlines and cheeks, which allows for a wider range of expression.

I think David ramps up the humor and puns more once Kirk takes over the art duties as well, but that might just be the shift in the direction of the series. Once Supergirl has some handle on the basics of her new life in Leesburg, David starts to unravel the nature of what she is (or has become, maybe.) She'd already begun to manifest new powers - flame wings, literal flame (not heat) vision -and seems to be attracting a particular kind of weirdo. Oddly dressed little boys who claim to be God, demons, fallen angels, a lady who changes into a superfast cyborg-horse person (that is also physically male, and no I'm not talking about Beta Ray Bill. Different cyborg horse-person.)

Supergirl also has to deal with people looking up to her, worshiping her, and the expectations that come with that, on top of the usual subplot stuff of parental issues, relationship issues, work troubles. That all culminates in a huge battle in issue 50 against a being out to claim Earth for his own, by forcing God to renounce his hold on it.

At which point David and Kirk pivot again. Now it's just Linda, with Golden Age Superman power levels, and the white t-shirt look Supergirl was sporting in the Timmverse Superman cartoon, with no idea where her other, angelic half, is. The story becomes a quest of sorts, with Linda having to team up with Buzz, and neither seeming to bring out the best in each other. That leaves Linda wondering if all the good she did, all the good that was in her, was really that other being. And if so, can she really change? Can Buzz, and does he even want to? 

That builds to another big showdown in issue 74, this time in the Garden of Eden. David pulls together threads he introduced over 40 issues earlier, and even uses elements from his Joker: Last Laugh tie-ins (in general, I find the event tie-ins and crossovers to be the weakest issues, but those two issues were pretty enjoyable.)

It feels like the book should end there. All the major threads tied up as they're going to get. But the book hung on another half-dozen issues, now with Ed Benes as artist. David brings in the Silver Age Kara Zor-El, somehow diverted to this world, and has her and Linda interact, until Linda tries to take Kara's place in the Silver Age (Earth-1?) timeline, including the showdown against the Anti-Monitor. Doesn't work, natch, no thanks to the always useless Hal Jordan Spectre. Plus, there's some idiot in a Skyrim mask out to kill Linda, but he can't find her.

It feels less like a Supergirl story than David lining up his future plans for Linda's character, which would play out over the Fallen Angel series at DC and then IDW.

As for Supergirl the concept, DC would bring back "Superman's cousin" in a Superman/Batman arc by Jeph Loeb and Michael Turner, then prove to have absolute fuck-all clue what to actually do with the character. So she bounced from one concept to the next - Outsiders this week, hanging out in Kandor with Power Girl the next week - probably getting the most traction when Waid and Kitson used her in their Legion of Super-Heroes book.

No comments: